Blake Unger Death, Obituary: New York Mills Homecoming King Killed in DWI Crash; Driver Izak Schermerhorn Arrested and Charged

May 29, 2025

OTTER TAIL COUNTY, MINNESOTA — A heartbreaking accident in western Minnesota has claimed the life of 18-year-old Blake Unger, a recent graduate and homecoming king at New York Mills High School. The young man was killed in a suspected alcohol-related crash late Saturday night, May 24, 2025, just miles from home.

Izak Schermerhorn, 19, a fellow graduate and the driver of the vehicle, has been arrested and is now facing serious criminal charges, including criminal vehicular homicide. Investigators believe alcohol played a significant role in the deadly incident, which has left the small community devastated and demanding answers.

Crash Details

According to officials from the Otter Tail County Sheriff’s Office and the Minnesota State Patrol, the accident happened around 11:45 p.m. Saturday night along Highway 10 near Deer Creek Township. Authorities report that Schermerhorn was driving a 2007 Ford Fusion westbound when the vehicle veered off the road, crashed into a ditch, and rolled several times.

Blake Unger, who was a passenger in the car, was ejected during the rollover. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Law enforcement confirmed he was not wearing a seatbelt at the time of the crash.

Schermerhorn sustained minor injuries and was taken to a local hospital. Blood tests later revealed his blood alcohol concentration was well above the legal limit. After receiving medical treatment, he was taken into custody.

Charges Against Schermerhorn

On Tuesday, the Otter Tail County Attorney’s Office formally charged Schermerhorn with criminal vehicular homicide, DWI, underage drinking, and reckless driving. Court records state that both young men had attended a graduation party earlier in the evening where underage drinking occurred.

At his initial court appearance Wednesday, Schermerhorn was visibly emotional. Bail was set at $100,000. His next court date is scheduled for next week.

Community Reeling from Sudden Loss

The tragic loss of Blake Unger has sent shockwaves through the New York Mills community. A 2024 graduate of the local high school, Unger was widely admired for his warmth, leadership, and spirit. He served as homecoming king and was a dedicated athlete, participating in both football and basketball.

The New York Mills School District released a statement expressing deep sorrow over the loss:

“Blake was an exceptional young man who touched the lives of so many. He was a leader, a teammate, and a friend. His presence brightened every room. We grieve this enormous loss alongside his family and friends.”

A candlelight vigil held Monday night at the school’s football field drew hundreds of mourners. Friends shared heartfelt stories and lit candles in memory of a life taken far too soon.

“He was going to do great things,” said close friend Lily Anderson. “He had his heart set on attending Bemidji State in the fall. He wanted to be a teacher, maybe a coach. None of this feels real.”

Blake Unger’s Legacy

Blake Unger was born and raised in New York Mills and had deep ties to the community. The oldest of three siblings, he was known for being kind, loyal, and full of energy. His parents, Mark and Stephanie Unger, released a statement calling their son “our sunshine” and encouraging others to make responsible choices.

“Blake brought joy everywhere he went. He was full of dreams, full of love. We hope his story reminds others to never drink and drive and to always protect one another.”

A scholarship in Blake’s honor is being established to support students who show leadership and community spirit—traits he exemplified throughout his short life.

Ongoing Investigation and Call for Accountability

The Otter Tail County Sheriff’s Office continues to investigate the circumstances of the party where alcohol was consumed. Officials say charges may be filed against those who provided alcohol to minors.

Sheriff Barry Fitzgibbons emphasized the importance of community involvement:

“This was a preventable tragedy. We must all work together—parents, schools, law enforcement—to ensure young people understand the dangers of impaired driving.”

A Painful Reminder

While Izak Schermerhorn awaits trial, the community is grappling with the complexity of the loss: one life ended, and another forever altered. Friends describe Unger and Schermerhorn as close, making the tragedy even more gut-wrenching.

“This isn’t just about criminal charges,” said Pastor Evan Mattson, who is helping the community cope. “This is about two lives, two families, and a town that will never be the same.”

If you or someone you know is struggling with grief or substance abuse, local resources are available for support.